"Nature has been friendly to the emergence and development of conscience and character. Those who will have all or nothing cannot be satisfied with this answer. Emergence and growth are not enough for them. They want something more than growth accompanied by toil and pain. They want final achievement." - John Dewey In this passage from "A Common Faith," John Dewey is warning against the dangers of utopianism, particularly in relation to the faith or the pursuit of ideal ends that he endorses in his work. Dewey suggests that nature has provided a favorable environment for the emergence and development of conscience and character. However, he recognizes that there are individuals who are not satisfied with this natural process of emergence and growth.
According to Dewey, these individuals who seek utopian ideals are not content with gradual progress and the ongoing effort required for growth. They desire more than just the process of development accompanied by the inevitable toil and pain that comes with it. They are driven by a desire for final achievement, a perfect and complete realization of their ideals.
By adopting a pragmatic approach, Dewey argues, we come to understand that our ideals do not aim at perfection but rather represent what is perceived to be the best, or the best that is currently available to us. The pursuit of ideals, in Dewey's view, is not about striving for an unattainable state of perfection but rather about making the best of the circumstances we find ourselves in.
Utopianism, according to Dewey, is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what the pursuit of ideals entails. Utopians believe in the possibility of achieving a flawless society, one devoid of problems and contradictions. However, Dewey contends that such a vision fails to account for the inherent complexities and uncertainties of human existence. It fails to recognize that social and cultural systems are intricate and constantly evolving, and that our knowledge and understanding are limited.
In Dewey's philosophy, the pursuit of ideals involves acknowledging the dynamic nature of human societies and the need for continuous growth and adaptation. It requires recognizing that progress is often incremental and that significant change is often achieved through a series of small steps rather than through a grand, all-encompassing transformation. Dewey argues that fixating on an idealized end-state can lead to a dogmatic mindset that dismisses the importance of ongoing development and the value of gradual progress.
Instead, Dewey advocates for an approach that embraces the ongoing process of growth and the practical steps needed to move towards our ideals. He encourages us to view our ideals as sources of inspiration and guidance, providing us with a vision of what is possible and motivating us to strive for improvement. However, he also emphasizes the importance of recognizing the limitations of our knowledge and the need for flexibility in adapting our strategies as circumstances change.
Dewey's warning about utopianism stems from his understanding of the limitations of human knowledge, the complexity of social and cultural systems, and the unpredictability of the future. He cautions against the dangers of fixating on idealized ends because they can lead to unrealistic expectations, dogmatism, and the rejection of incremental progress. By emphasizing the importance of growth and the ongoing process of development, Dewey suggests that the pursuit of ideal ends should be tempered by a recognition of the dynamic and evolving nature of human societies.
In endorsing faith or the pursuit of ideal ends, Dewey advocates for a pragmatic approach that balances the recognition of ideals as sources of inspiration and guidance with a commitment to the practical steps needed to achieve them. He emphasizes the importance of a flexible and adaptive mindset that can navigate the complexities of social change, rather than seeking a static and perfect state that may never be attainable.
Produced by Clint Warren - Aided by ChatGPT
Comments